Porta Rossa Hotel Firenze, Colbert Collection
Sources: the reviews behind this analysis
We show 5 of the 52 reviews we read, with a direct link to each one on its original site. Open any of them and check that the quote and the count are real.
-
Kathy Patterson ★★★★★ 3 August 2026
“Here’s a polished Google review you can post: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Our stay at NH Collection Firenze Porta Rossa was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, the hospitality made us feel genuinely welcomed and cared for. Every member of...”
Backs up: staff Open on Google -
Heinz Müller ★★★★★ 28 July 2026
“We got completely lost on our arrival in the city center. A call to the hotel: "Stay here, I'll send someone!" Minutes later, an employee took over and brought us safely to check-in. We didn't have to worry about our luggage; everything...”
Backs up: location Open on Google -
Esteban de Latorre ★★★★★ 15 July 2026
“Located in the heart of Florence, just a mere 5 minutes from Piazza della Signoria, this hotel is considered the oldest in Italy. Formerly part of the NH brand, it's now a Colbert Collection hotel by Minor Hotels. Its exquisite and refined...”
Backs up: breakfast Open on Google -
Kim Lin ★★★★★ 7 July 2026
“I have stayed at many five-star hotels around the world. I am always impressed by the beautiful facilities, elegant rooms, excellent amenities, and attention to detail that come with luxury hotels. This hotel delivered on all of those...”
-
Leo Bearman ★★★★★ 20 June 2026
“We had a wonderful stay at the NH Collection in Florence, which I believe was in the process of rebranding to Porta Rossa during our visit. Everything about the experience felt consistent with what you would expect from a five-star hotel....”
How we pick them: one review per published signal, so every percentage can be checked on its own. Nothing is edited, only shortened.
What guests keep saying
-
staffpraised 37 / 71%
“Thanks to the wonderful staff.”
-
locationpraised 28 / 54%
“It's centrally located yet peaceful.”
-
breakfastpraised 20 / 38%
“The breakfast was spectacular.”
-
the restaurantpraised 8 / 15%
“This also applies to breakfast, the restaurant, and the room.”
-
how quiet it ispraised 5 / 10%
“It's centrally located yet peaceful.”
